Nowadays it has become cliché, to bash politicians just for the sake of it. The uninitiated don’t even know what is the work that our corporators really do. So we at Parivartan came up with an idea why not investigate what really do the corporators do from the funds that are allocated to them i.e. 20 lacs per year per ward. Though this amount may seem small but in 5 years but it accounts to Rs 1 crore, from which various good projects can be implemented and executed successfully. Just the question is do the corporators have the vision and will to utilize the funds and do the citizens think that vision is aligned to the needs of their own ward?
In this first of a kind project, with the help of RTI, we collected all the information of 144 Corporators about the work that they have executed from the funds they were bound to get between years 2007 to 2011. Then we deduced facts and depicted them in percentage so that common citizen can understand. This report card as you will see includes utilization of funds, highlights of the funds utilized, attendance in General body meetings of PMC and the number of questions that they have asked in GB meetings.
This Project’s objectives are in complete resonance with Parivartan’s below core principles of good governance.
1) Complete Transparency in the functioning :
With help of RTI we were able to get all the information of the utilization of ward level funds of all the corporators. Some of the ward office’s had given us systematic detailed information for this RTI, while some ward offices had misplaced information and later gave them to us in haphazard manner. So next time when we ask for this information, we will receive all the information of all the ward offices in systematic manner from this year’s experience which is what “Good Governance” is all about.
With help of RTI we were able to get all the information of the utilization of ward level funds of all the corporators. Some of the ward office’s had given us systematic detailed information for this RTI, while some ward offices had misplaced information and later gave them to us in haphazard manner. So next time when we ask for this information, we will receive all the information of all the ward offices in systematic manner from this year’s experience which is what “Good Governance” is all about.
2) Accountability of the Government :
By this report card, the corporators will know that common citizens have an eye on them and they are accountable to us for the tax we pay. So when they come to us with their request for vote, they better have a track record to match it. They will know that their low attendance will not go unnoticed. And we don’t want bench warmers as our elected representatives they better ask some relevant questions in the meeting.
3) Proper Planning :
Ward Level Funds are a wonderful way to properly plan and execute the projects that the citizens really want. With some shocking facts revealed by this report card hopefully the elected representatives’ will better be prepared with an action plan to effectively utilize the funds this time around.
4) Participation of Citizens :
We are playing the part of “Democracy, by the people “by preparing this report card. We as active and educated citizens have come ahead and taken the assiduous efforts in summarizing this information, so that our elected representatives’ get the message that, we citizens are closely monitoring their work and that we are no pushovers and we are not ignorant any more. We are keeping close vigilance of your actions.
5) Voters Awareness :
This is one of the important objectives of this report card. Only when enough information is available for a voter then only he can make an informed decision for casting his vote .This Report card will provide him with facts about the existing corporators and the kind of work they have done. So then he can decide whether to re-elect this candidate or not.
Thus by this Project we are hoping that citizens would think twice before casting their vote. If you look into the report cards we are not trying to give grades or claim any corporator good or bad.We are nobody to make a comment on that. We are just trying to state the facts and we are resting it on the collective intelligence of all the people to decide who has done a better Job.
We all have got our report cards since school and college. Even in corporate companies appraisal system is there to evaluate an employee. It’s high time that our elected representatives are evaluated and who better than us common citizens to do it!! So we present you with Corporators Report Card .
Now Think and Vote !!!
Here are their Report Cards :
To Download : Click on the Ward name. You will be taken to Google Docs page.
After opening the file, click on File Menu -> Download Original
AUNDH
KOTHRUD
SANGAMWADI
TILAK ROAD
GHOLE ROAD
BIBVEWADI
BHAVANI PETH
NAGAR ROAD
HADAPSAR
DHANKAWADI
DP ROAD
SAHKAR NAGAR
VISHRAMBAUG WADA
KARVE NAGAR
COMPILED REPORT CARD OF ALL WARDS
Corporators with Criminal Record
AUNDH
KOTHRUD
SANGAMWADI
TILAK ROAD
GHOLE ROAD
BIBVEWADI
BHAVANI PETH
NAGAR ROAD
HADAPSAR
DHANKAWADI
DP ROAD
SAHKAR NAGAR
VISHRAMBAUG WADA
KARVE NAGAR
COMPILED REPORT CARD OF ALL WARDS
Corporators with Criminal Record
Fabulous Job , Its really awesome.!!!
ReplyDeleteI sincerely hope all over voters read the report BEFORE making their decision to vote. And what about their political bosses? They also must read the report to decide whom they shall field for forthcoming elections. I guess we all have been rules for too many years by corruption starting at the lowest level of corporators till the highest in political arena. If only all the money was utilised for what it was meant for - we would the best nation in the world.
ReplyDeleteI seriously miss the “right to reject”.
ReplyDeleteVery good job ...but wanted to know about my area ie PCMC!!
ReplyDeleteJust found out about this blog. Definitely a good start. How can we verify the work done? I guess the only way is to go and see for ourselves (physically).
ReplyDeleteHowever I am doubtful of the veracity of data -
e.g. I looked at Kothrud ward.
1. Highlights (fund details) for Leena Pansare and Dileep Umbarkar are the same!
2. Photos for Pritviraj Sutar and Murlidhar Mohol are same.
wow so much money spent on benches - btw where are these benches?
ReplyDeletegood work doods ...saw you guys on ibn lokmat .. u guys rocks!! ...
ReplyDeleteplease dont be lazy ...while downloading "Compiled Report Card of all Wards.pdf" ...my opera browser doesnt show file size in mb...
keep up the good work!
if i were in pune ...i would give u dinner
Great Job!!!!!!!! You have need to display Best Nagar sevak Rank wise means actual spend money actual work!!!!!!
ReplyDeleteGood work! It would have been great if could also compile and post the ward-vise data about the current PMC election candidates with various details like their education, political experience/history, social work, criminal background etc.
ReplyDeleteKeep up the good work.
All the best!
i want a general platform where all voters can discuss all the problems
ReplyDeletethere should be Nagarsevak wise list & any one can comment directly to particular Nagarsevak
because of that we can tell the problems in less time & it will be more helpful for oldsters
one of the common sentence we can skip "BHAU meeting madhe aahet........"
ya mule nagarsevkanchi jagrukta matdaranchya lakshat yeil
no this is not a survey . In our ward 61 62, though people are educated they still don't know to whom they should elect. They are literally foolish . According to your survey they shld understand that existing corportor are not good. as looking from their Report card . They have not utilise funds in proper way & seeing their attendance Year wise distribution of Questions asked in General Body was Zero. & now he is the Hero . Again he came to utilise funds for his private purpose .
ReplyDelete